Specific praise proves you actually noticed, which is the whole point. Generic praise proves only that you needed something to say.
— Not the Epilogue, 35. Appreciative Communication
The trouble with “good job” isn’t that it’s insincere. Most of the time it’s genuinely meant. The trouble is that it’s automatic — a reflex we reach for the way we reach for “you too” when the waiter tells us to enjoy our meal. And the people on the receiving end can tell the difference between a reflex and a response, even when they can’t name what’s missing. What’s missing is evidence that we were actually paying attention.
This matters more, not less, as we get older. By the second half of life, most of us have stopped needing applause. What we’re hungry for is accuracy — someone who sees the specific thing we did and says so.
Notice the choice, not just the outcome
Generic praise usually lands on the result: the dinner was good, the presentation went well, the garden looks great. Specific praise lands on the choice someone made to get there. That’s a different target, and it’s the one that actually teaches something.
When you tell your daughter “the presentation went well,” you’ve told her nothing she can repeat. When you tell her “the way you paused before the hard question — that gave everyone time to actually think about it instead of just watching you sweat,” you’ve named a decision. She can do that again on purpose. She now knows what worked, not just that something did.
Try this: Next time you’re about to say “good job” to someone, stop and ask yourself one question first: what did they actually decide to do here? Not what happened, but what choice sits underneath it. Say that instead. If you can’t find the choice, you probably haven’t been watching closely enough — and that’s worth noticing about yourself too.
Let the specificity include the cost
Here’s a piece people often miss: specific praise is more credible when it acknowledges what the effort cost, not just what it produced. “You handled that difficult client well” is nice. “You stayed calm for forty-five minutes with someone who was actively trying to provoke you, and you never once raised your voice” tells the person you saw the effort of restraint, not just the pleasant surface result.
This matters especially with people who are quietly struggling — a spouse managing a hard diagnosis, a friend rebuilding after a loss, a colleague learning something new later in life than they’d like to admit. The polished version of their effort is easy to praise. The strained, unglamorous middle of it is what actually needed noticing.
Try this: When you praise someone, try naming one thing that was hard about what they did, alongside what they did. “You finished the report” becomes “You finished the report even though half your data came in late — and you didn’t just wing it, you went back and reworked the timeline.” That extra clause is where the person feels seen instead of just complimented.
Resist the urge to praise faster than you can look
Part of why “good job” survives is speed. It costs nothing to say and requires no observation. Specific praise takes a beat longer — you have to actually watch, actually think, before you speak. In a culture that rewards quick responses, that beat feels inefficient. It isn’t. It’s the entire mechanism.
This is worth remembering with grandchildren too, since adults often try to be encouraging in bulk. “Great job” heard all day long is easy to discount. “You kept trying different ways to stack those blocks even after they fell twice — that’s exactly how builders think” is clearly about the child and not a script.
Try this: Pick one relationship this week — a spouse, a friend, a grandchild — where you tend to praise on autopilot. For seven days, replace every instance of “good job” or “nice work” with one sentence that names the specific thing you saw. If you catch yourself unable to produce that sentence, use it as a signal to look more carefully next time, rather than defaulting back to the easy phrase.
None of this is complicated, but it is a habit, and habits take deliberate practice to unlearn, especially ones as socially convenient as generic praise. This is just the entry point.
Go deeper. Not the Epilogue takes this further. Start with the free Not the Epilogue starter: one page, no signup.